Broken Christians in a Hurting World

One of my favorite DC Talk songs opens with a powerful quote: “The greatest single cause of atheism in the world today is Christians who acknowledge Jesus with their lips, walk out the door, and deny Him by their lifestyle.” I used to rewind the track just to hear those words again. Penned by Brennan Manning, author of The Ragamuffin Gospel, this quote gained fame through DC Talk’s song “What If I Stumble.” Ironically, one of the band’s members, Michael Tait, later faced headlines for sexual assault and drug abuse. Tait’s actions are now linked with people who are wounded which has left many of his fan base whispering claims of ‘church hurt.’ Though he believed the song’s lyrics when he sang them, the self-fulfilling prophecy of his fall is a stark reminder of human imperfection.

The Dark Legacy of Magdalene Laundries and the Subsequent Church Hurt

In Ireland’s Catholic history lies a painful chapter: the Magdalene Laundries. These institutions, meant to reform “fallen” women in the 18th century, often became places of abuse and dehumanization. In Tuam, a mass grave of nearly 800 children was uncovered at the Bon Secours Mother and Baby Home. Headlines sensationalize the story, by claiming bodies were buried in a septic tank, the truth remains heartbreaking. 800 children died in a facility meant to protect them. Women faced harsh labor, physical and psychological abuse, and loss of identity as nuns changed their names to erase their past. What began as a mission to build community through faith left countless women and children broken, highlighting the devastating impact of church hurt.

When a Shining City Dims

What connects these stories—DC Talk’s fall and the Magdalene Laundries’ horrors? Both involve well-meaning Christian entities causing deep church hurt. From Hillsong’s scandals, including a pastor’s affair and allegations of volunteer exploitation, to the Magdalene Laundries’ abuses, these stories reveal a pattern of flawed humans failing to live up to their calling. As someone who grew up inspired by Hillsong’s music, I’ve learned to approach such stories with discernment, recognizing that media often amplifies flaws in Christian communities. Yet, these scandals don’t shake my faith. Why? Because humans, not God, are behind these failures. Our faith must rest in Christ, not in fallible leaders or institutions.

The Greatest Commission and Commandment

Jesus calls us to make disciples of all nations (Matthew 28:18-20), but we’re still broken people in need of His grace. Even passionate Christian leaders, from biblical times to today, are fallible. Carl Lentz, the Hillsong pastor caught in scandal, owned his mistakes without deflection. His raw admission of guilt and ongoing journey toward redemption, shared through his family’s podcast, reflect the gospel’s power to heal. This openness reminds us that true Christian community is built on humility and grace, not perfection. Church hurt may wound, but Christ’s love restores.

King David: A Sinner Redeemed

King David’s story mirrors this truth. Despite committing adultery and murder, David’s repentance led to redemption. His son Solomon, born to David and Bathsheba, became a testament to God’s grace. As Christians, we’re called to love others as Christ loves us, following the Golden Rule: “Do to others as you would have them do to you.” Church hurt often stems from ego, but humility—asking, “Is this true, kind, necessary?”—keeps us grounded in Christ’s love and fosters authentic community.

To Those Wounded by Church Hurt

To those grappling with church hurt and questioning the gospel’s goodness, I urge you to look beyond the headlines. Michael Tait’s apology acknowledges his brokenness and need for grace. His actions aren’t excusable, but are a desperate example of the need for grace. The Irish church, humbled by the Magdalene Laundries’ legacy, is working to identify the remains of those 800 children. The Irish government is seeking reconciliation through transparency. In 2022, I stood in a half-full arena as Hillsong’s Joel Houston shared how the band nearly canceled their tour amid scandal but chose to keep sharing the gospel through music. Their raw, worshipful performance showed that God can work through broken vessels to build community.

Church hurt is real, but it doesn’t define the gospel. The greatest Christian leaders are still human, needing Jesus’ grace as much as anyone. Look past their failures to the truth of Christ’s love. Healing isn’t about excusing pain but recognizing that God’s grace shines through our brokenness, creating space for true community.

To find more about our community – checkout our website! To find more resources about how to work through faith struggles and finding your community, join our Skool page!